Monday, July 16, 2012

More Jail Sentences. More stupidity.

So, to update you on the latest campaign against bloggers in Oman, I just received an SMS update (SABQ Service) from the government with the following info: "Mohammed Al Badi, Mohammed Al Habsi, Abdullah Al Siyabi, Talib Al Abri, Abdullah Al Arimi and Muna Hardan are handed one-year prison sentences and a fine of 1000 OMR for defamation and violating the laws of information technology".
.
It's official. A Dhofari girl is involved and her sentence is not just one year, but 18 months. Before activists and human rights organizations get all excited and start calling for the release of these so-called  'human rights defenders', surely the government should reveal what exactly were their crimes? If they're going to publish full names and photos (tomorrow's newspaper), surely a little detail would be useful?  As far as I know, Muna was continuously defaming and insulting His Majesty and the Omani people online under the nickname "Dhofari Rose". As much as I love freedom of speech, I think she was pretty stupid given the current circumstances of freedom of expression in Oman. (in my head: WHAT WAS SHE THINKING, DAMMIT?!)  
.
Every person who publicly and continuously defames His Majesty is asking for trouble. Regardless of what she thinks (and thinking out loud in Oman can get you into serious trouble), she knows what the current situation is in Oman, and she knew what was coming. I'm not saying I like the current situation, but I believe in being sensible and choosing your battles wisely.
.
Defaming for the sake of defaming isn't going to help anyone. What was her cause? Did she have one? Were her accusations based on fact? What's going to happen now? She's the first woman ever in Dhofar to be publicly sentenced. Is her tribe going to interfere? Is Wasta going to play a vital role in getting her bailed out? She's a naive little university student, not an activist.
.
My only criticism of the government in this case would be the exaggerated unnecessary prison sentences (six months for holding a poster that sort-of criticizes the Sultan?!), publishing photos of the detainees in prison uniform, and withholding information. If you're trying to teach people a lesson, share details. What rules did these bloggers break? What are the new limitations? The rest of us would like to know. His Majesty is off limits, but what else? I'm not interested in being plucked out of my home in the middle of the night for a post I wrote two years ago. Must I go through every single blog post and review? I don't want to see more people end up in jail for speaking their minds.
.
Choose your battles wisely. Oman is not a free country.. Dhofari Gucci is not happy.

8 comments:

  1. What happened to the Linoleum Surfer? Do you happen to know? Did he cross one of the invisible lines? I really liked his stuff...

    ReplyDelete
  2. is muna the shy arab rebellious girl blog?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Anonymous 1 : I have no idea what happened to Linoleum Surfer but I hope he reappears soon.
    Anonyomous 2: No, it's not Shy Arab Rebellious Girl. Mimi may be rebellious but she has never insulted His Majesty.

    ReplyDelete
  4. WTF - this is serious business. Whatever happened to the peaceful Oman I used to know? Authorities need to be careful or another Arab Spring might erupt.

    Bill

    ReplyDelete
  5. Dear Nadia, your insider's knowledge is always a pleasure to read. I don't think any country is totally free. Maybe the United States come close, but sooner or later you will run into (unexpected) boundaries of freedom (Easy for me to say here in Europe). I believe that carefully exploring those boundaries will ultimately stretch them. Aggressive violation of these borders will only create anger between those who maintain the border and those who believe they should cross it. Don't get me wrong, I firmly believe in pushing the boundaries, to explore new freedom but only to an extend that will let you live and tell about to those behind. Be brave, but not foolish. To quote Yoda “Fear is the path to the dark side. Fear leads to anger. Anger leads to hate. Hate leads to suffering.”
    Kind regards,
    JB

    ReplyDelete
  6. You say that Muna is stupid, but your posts are basically the same thing. You are just saying these things to save your Ass.

    pot calling the kettle black

    ReplyDelete
  7. The Linoleum Surfer will be back soon :)

    ReplyDelete
  8. Badr, saving my ass from what? :) Fortunately for me and for everyone, I am a great admirer of His Majesty. I may not like policies in Oman and certain regulations, but that's a different matter.

    ReplyDelete